- Yashin, Alexei
- Yastrzemski, Carl
- Yawkey, Tom
- Yelle, Stephane
- Yoder, Todd
- York, Michael
- Youkilis, Kevin
- Young, Bill
- Young, Brian
- Young, Bryant
- Young, Cy
- Young, Dmitri
- Young, Eric
- Young, Kevin
- Young, Mike
- Young, Scott
- Youngblood, Jack
- Yount, Robin
- Yzerman, Steve
